Israeli lesbian composer moved to tears by NY haredi singer’s Yiddish version of her classic tune
An unofficial, feel-good anthem that has been embraced (or co-opted, depending on your point of view) by all sides along Israel’s spectrum has again served as a bridge, this time between a haredi Ashkenazi pop star and the Sephardic, lesbian Israeli musician who wrote the music.
Written in 1982 when a right-wing Likud government was waging a controversial war in Lebanon, “I Have No Other Land” (“Ein Li Eretz Acheret” in Hebrew) speaks of lyricist Ehud Manor’s love for Hebrew but features a pledge to “not remain silent and sing” to a country that “has changed its face.” Manor’s widow, Ofra Fuchs, said last year that the song was intended as a left-wing protest song.
Yet, like Bruce Springsteen’s “Born in the USA,” Manor’s song had such wide appeal that it transcended its own politics and was embraced by all sides — including settlers who adopted the song as an anthem against the 2005 pullout from Gaza.
Last week, New York’s haredi singer Lipa Schmeltzer sang it in Yiddish, accompanied on guitar by the song’s original composer, the Israeli musician Korin Allal.